A diverted St. Patrick’s Day post | Two (four?) surprising green eyeliner dupes

So, I was going to do another colour post for today – in green, of course. But while I was swatching the eyeliners I’d picked out, I came to the (rather startling) realization that they were more or less two sets of almost-perfect green eyeliner dupes.

And this, of course, absolutely begged to be covered.

L-R: MAC So There Jade, Marcelle Caribbean, Clinique Intense Ivy, Marcelle Metal Green.

(Click to enlarge!)

On the left, we have MAC’s Powerpoint Eye Pencil in So There Jade and Marcelle’s Waterproof Eye Crayon in Caribbean, two iridescent aqua-green longwearing waterproof liners. MAC describes So There Jade as a “light green jade,” but I call bullshit – I’d say it’s more of a metallic seafoam green than “jade,” and I’ve been to China.

(See, that’s funny, because jade is “the” Chinese stone, but you don’t actually have to be Chinese to recognize that Jade is typically, well, green, with perhaps a bit of blue.)

(… and now we’re making tongue-in-cheek jibes at hipster racism and the fact that it is WRONG, ANDERSON, WRONG! at ten o’clock at night. Sherlock references and passive-aggression at the beauty industry over sexism, racism, and orientalism: just a regular Saturday at theNotice.)

But, back on topic. Caribbean is So There Jade‘s prettier, smarter twin sister – she’s smoother, better priced, and more opaque. The Marcelle is a little brighter and bluer, but honestly, there’s no contest: if you’re in Canada (or you’re ordering Marcelle online from the US), go with Caribbean!

Marcelle Lux Metallic Liquid Eyeliner in Jade over the straight swatches, and alone on the far L&R.

Other eyeliners in the same order as above: MAC So There Jade, Marcelle Caribbean, Clinique Intense Ivy, and Marcelle Metal Green.

On the right hand side of the swatches, we have Clinique’s Quickliner Intense in Intense Ivy (a recent release – review of the formula soon!) and Marcelle’s Waterproof Eye Crayon in Metal Green. And you’d expect that I’d be all over the Marcelle again, right? Because that would only make sense.

Content on theNotice rarely makes sense, though, so then there’s that. (I’m sorry, I’m so sorry; I can’t seem to be able to turn off the meta tonight!)

While startlingly similar, the differences between Clinique’s Quickliner Intense and Marcelle’s Waterproof Eye Crayon are more varied, both in shade and in performance. Intense Ivy features a creamier formula, easier to apply & with a more complex shade, but Metal Green is cheaper, water-resistant, and makes it through more of my sixteen hour days.

As for which one I’d recommend? Well, that depends. If your lids aren’t too oily, go for the Clinique Quickliner Intense – the buttery texture is to-die-for, and the more nuanced shade of Intense Ivy is (har, har) really intense. It’s more black, more green, more metallic, and contains tiny gold flecks that just take my breath away. If your lids are oily, though, opt for the Marcelle Waterproof Eye CrayonMetal Green is still breathtaking, and wears much better on my lids.

I should probably start rambling about now, but there’s one last thing we have to go over: I compulsively add Marcelle’s Lux Metallic eyeliner in Jade to all of my green liner swatches. It’s a bit of an addiction, admittedly, but can you really blame me? It’s gorgeous. 


For a green swatch post that actually managed to happen without getting sidetracked, here’s last year’s St. Paddy’s mini-post: Green swatches for St. P

Previous Post Next Post

You may also like


  • Reply Carros Beauty

    Nice post!

    March 18, 2012 at 12:48 AM
  • Reply sharlynn

    Omg..such gorgeous greens! I'm totally a green/blue/teal girl if it comes to colors on the eyes. I find it complements brown eyes so well! :)
    My recent post Review: Hada Labo AHA/BHA Exfoliating Face Wash (Japanese skincare)

    March 18, 2012 at 5:59 AM
  • Reply emmabovary

    Love the comparisons, and this post made me laugh :) Lemming for a nice green eyeliner, I only own two
    My recent post Baby Lips Loves NY! + giveaway!

    March 18, 2012 at 6:22 AM
  • Reply mostlysunnybunny

    Oooo is that MAC Humid we're looking at in the picture? I used it yesterday and was super proud of myself lol
    My recent post FOTD: Happy Saint Patrick’s Day featuring Urban Decay 24/7 in Stash, Mildew, NARS Paramaribo, MAC Humid, & Wet n’ Wild Comfort Zone

    March 18, 2012 at 12:05 PM
  • Reply Larie

    That Clinique liner…I need it in my life. It's gorgeous! And I just have this soft spot for greens. I don't know. Adding it to the list. You naughty, naughty girl, Rae :P
    My recent post Wedding Series FOTD #2: A Brighter Red Lip

    March 18, 2012 at 12:39 PM
  • Reply Mimi

    Sigh. Rae. Why do you do this to me? I love how you make these gorgeous liners look, but I'll be honest. I'll buy them. And NEVER use them.

    March 18, 2012 at 8:19 PM
  • Reply Jess

    Oh, Rae, how I love your Sherlock references…
    And the colours are gorgeous too! Hahaha~ Always nice to see Marcelle products get some more lovin'.

    March 20, 2012 at 11:49 AM
  • Leave a Reply