Alternate post title: “Why I don’t like Smashbox Caviar!”
Top: L’Oreal HiP cream liner.
Left to right: Smashbox Caviar cream liner, thickly then thinly, Urban Decay 24/7 Zero cream-pencil.
After washing my hands, quite vigorously around the HiP liner which would! not! come! off!:
In short, I dislike Caviar because it is a) shiny, b) not very black, and c) easy to rinse off. The opposites of these are the reasons why I love my L’Oreal HiP liner — it’s very black, stays on like metal in comparison to other gel/cream liners that I’ve tried, and dries to a lovely satin finish!Somewhere, I have more black liner photos for a future comparison review of HiP, Smashbox, and MAC. Somewhere… Edit: Wait! I lied. It seems like I’ve already posted that; check it out here!
