Follow:

Adventures in Theatre Makeup

I’m a huge fan of theatre makeup — for everyday use. (Yes, I really did just say that.) I’m not sure how many of you have done theatre before, but those of you who have surely remember days of gross, slimy, caked-on makeup!

Thing is, it doesn’t have to be like that. Theatre makeup can work amazingly for day looks, too — you just have to really work the products in and sheer them out. The trick is using as little as possible; theatre makeup is made to be super pigmented, which means that for everyday uses, you can work the products into a feels-like-nothing state and still get great payoff. If you ask me, theatre makeup puts high-end pigmentation to shame… and it does it at drugstore prices!

Lovely “life-appropriate” theatre makeup out of the Ben Nye catalogue 
What we love about theatre makeup:
  • Absolutely incredible pigmentation and wear time. They’re made to stand out under and stand up to super-hot stage lighting, after all.
  • Dirt-cheap prices. Pans of foundation for under $10? Sign us up!
  • Many of the cream foundations (especially the older ones) are silicone-free. Which isn’t to say that they all are, though — check the ingredients label!
What we don’t love about it:
  • It can be really, really hard to find, especially in smaller cities — which means that shade-matching for foundation is even more difficult than normal!
  • You don’t get any snazzy packaging, but… we’ll make the compromise.
But without further adieu: a few reviews. NOTE: I’m not affiliated with Ben Nye, and I don’t think they’re necessarily the best. It’s just that they’re all I’ve tried, and I’ve been thrilled with the line!

Ben Nye Creme Highlight in Ultralight
Not much to say about this one. It was a highlighter; I liked it. Personally, I love the idea of matte/satin highlighters that are just a touch lighter than your own skintone, but that’s just me! I know that shimmery highlighters are very “in” right now (and by “now” we mean “always.”) It’s just… I’ve never been a huge fan of shimmer. We all know that.


Ultralight in particular is great because it’s so, well, light! If you have a creme foundation that’s a little too light, mixing a bit of this in as a shade-lightener is a great alternative to buying a new shade altogether. And, for those about NC30 or below, it makes a great natural highlight when it’s (a) sheered out or (b) blended with a small amount of foundation for a truly customized highlight shade.
Clockwise from top left: Dusty Rose Creme Rouge, Raspberry Creme Rouge, Ultra Fair Creme Foundation, Ultralight Highlight. 

The entire highlight range: (if you’re interested in Ben Nye products, I highly recommend flipping through their online catalogue — it’s quite extensive!)

Ben Nye Creme Rouge in Dusty Rose and Raspberry
These were definitely my favourites of the bunch, which is saying a lot! You need so little product to get a gorgeous, unbelievably natural flush, and it lasts all day long. We used these two Creme Rouges extensively on-set, and I kid you not, both of them translate just as beautifully and boldly on NC55 skin as they do on NW10 skin.

Top: Dusty Rose, Raspberry
Bottom circle: the two blended together and blended out. Lovely, non? 

More things to note: these are the softest, creamiest creme blushers I’ve ever found, making them optimal for blending different shades together. Plus, they won’t dry out on you, and are an amazing $5 each! I kind of scare myself by saying this, but… I’d pick up a Ben Nye Creme Rouge over a Bobbi Brown Pot Rouge any day.

Another tip: try applying pigmented cream blushes with a duo-fibre stippling brush or a foundation brush for a flawless, seamless finish.

The rest of the creme blush range: (I have my eye on Red, of course, as well as Carnation Pink. And everything else.)
Catalogue photos via Ben Nye.

Check back later today for a review of Ben Nye’s foundation… which comes in over 50 different shades!

Share:
Previous Post Next Post
Disclaimer: this post may contain affiliate links and/or products submitted to theNotice for editorial consideration. To find out more, please visit our About/Disclaimer page.

You may also like